
In 2020, Zohran Mamdani had a simple instruction for New York City Hall. “NO to fake cuts – defund the police.” Five years later, with a mayoral election to win, he had a different message. “I am not running to defund the police,” he told reporters. New Yorkers can now judge both statements against what he’s done with the job.
Mamdani and Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch announced Monday that the NYPD will disband its Strategic Response Group next spring. The department will reassign the unit’s roughly 500 officers, many to counterterrorism. An unarmed civilian division will work with protest organizers before and during demonstrations, alongside a new NYPD team. Sworn officers will still handle arrests. The mayor gets to tell his activist base he abolished the unit. Tisch gets to tell the rest of New York that police will still show up when a crowd turns violent.
BREAKING: NYC Mayor Mamdani announces he is disbanding the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group, which handles protest response and counterterrorism operations. pic.twitter.com/KUjXgXnj4n
— Breaking911 (@Breaking911) November 16, 2026
The budget tells the more revealing story. Former Mayor Eric Adams had funded a plan to add 5,000 uniformed officers over three years. Mamdani scrapped it in February. By June, he was on television defending a much smaller increase of 580 officers to support training and staff a new Bronx command. His allies in the Democratic Socialists of America objected. Weeks later, City Council members discovered that the 580 positions had disappeared from the final budget. Monday’s reorganization leaves headcount alone. The earlier budget decisions settled how many officers Tisch would have to reassign.
The politics run deeper than one budget fight. Mamdani came out of a socialist movement whose New York chapter promoted a Times Square rally the day after Hamas attacked Israel, drawing condemnation even from fellow Democrats. By this June, Mamdani-backed socialists were beating candidates Hakeem Jeffries supported. Yet even Mamdani found out how little standing he had with some of the activists on his left. When he attended an October 7 vigil organized by Israelis for Peace last month, protesters outside the barricades chanted “Globalize the intifada” and “We don’t want no Zionists here.”
“New Yorkers exercising their constitutional right to protest should not be met with the same police response as a terrorism threat,” Mamdani said Monday. The SRG faced lawsuits over its conduct during the George Floyd protests in 2020. But Jewish New Yorkers have some experience with what happens when activists decide who should answer for a war overseas. In March 2024, volunteers got down on their hands and knees to scrub graffiti from the sidewalk outside Effy’s Café, a kosher restaurant in Manhattan. Ten months later, vandals hit Miriam, an Israeli-owned restaurant in Brooklyn.
In Philadelphia, marchers stopped outside a kosher falafel shop and chanted, “Goldie, Goldie, you can’t hide, we charge you with genocide.” In Michigan, federal prosecutors allege that a campaign to force the University of Michigan to divest from Israel reached the Jewish Federation of Metropolitan Detroit. And in the Paris suburb of Sarcelles in 2014, a mob chanting antisemitic slogans burned a kosher grocery and other Jewish-owned businesses. A Philadelphia falafel cook and a French grocer had about the same say over Israeli policy. Both had a storefront people could find.
Mamdani has spent years telling New Yorkers what he thinks a protester ought to be able to expect from the police. A Jewish restaurant owner deserves an answer just as plain. If the next march stops outside her door and someone starts threatening the people coming in for lunch, how quickly will the city put an officer on that sidewalk? She already knows who’ll be there the next morning to scrub it.
[READ MORE: Van Hollen Will Do Anything To Take Over The Senate]










