Democratic Governance Leads To Disaster In St. Louis

The liberal belief that society just runs on autopilot has led to disaster in one of America’s biggest city. A deadly EF3 tornado tore through St. Louis on the evening of May 16, leaving five dead, more than 5,000 buildings damaged, and a political storm in its wake. But the tragedy wasn’t just in the wind. As the twister churned across the Central West End and into North City, not a single outdoor warning siren sounded. The city’s emergency alert system—managed by the Democratic administration of Mayor Cara Spencer—failed at the most basic level: to warn people in time to take shelter.

The St. Louis Emergency Management Agency (CEMA) blamed the failure on “human error.” Specifically, CEMA Commissioner Sarah Russell, a Jones appointee, was attending a workshop less than a mile from the siren control station but never activated the system. Instead, she issued what the mayor’s office later called an “ambiguous directive” to the fire department, which led to confusion and inaction. The result was silence while a tornado leveled parts of the city.

Five people in St. Louis died in the severe weather and Spencer described it as “one of the worst storms — absolutely.” 

Great accountability questions from @shoshana_stahl last night. Notice how it takes three times before CEMA Commissioner Sarah Russell finally admits CEMA staffers were at a workshop when they should've been sounding an alarm. Russell also blames fire dept, old battered sirens. https://t.co/JvHSRqvX4A pic.twitter.com/9g7jCYBxJm

— Mark Maxwell (@MarkMaxwellTV) May 20, 2025

“The direction was not clear,” Spencer said at a news conference Wednesday morning about the phone call. Russel did not clearly direct the person at the Fire Department to press the button to activate the sirens, she said, adding, “It’s my understanding that the button was not pushed,” according to CBS News.

However, even if someone had pressed the button at the Fire Department, city officials learned Tuesday that the button was not working.

“Work to repair the button began Tuesday afternoon and is expected to be completed within days,” Spencer’s office said.

The button at the CEMA office was functioning, and Fire Department personnel will be stationed there 24/7 to activate the sirens if needed, the office said.

Some have blamed DEI for the mistake as it appears that Russell goes by “they, them” pronouns,

Russell’s own siren protocol—drafted in 2021 during Jones’ first year as mayor—was never fully implemented. According to city officials, it required activation through the fire department’s alarm office, with two backup locations in case of failure. None were used. Russell is now on paid administrative leave as an external investigation begins.

The failure has unleashed a wave of fury, particularly in North City, where residents say they’ve long been neglected by City Hall. Now, with lives lost and homes destroyed, many are asking how a city could be so unprepared—with the technology in place, but no leadership to use it.

The siren debacle is just the latest symptom of deeper Democratic rot in St. Louis. Entire blocks of downtown sit abandoned. Violent crime is rampant. The city’s police force is so short-staffed that some neighborhoods go hours without coverage. Once again, liberal governance in St. Louis has proven incapable of managing basic public safety.

The political fallout has already begun. Last week, the St. Louis Democratic Central Committee endorsed Mayor Jones’ challenger, Cara Spencer, in a 15–11 vote. Spencer has walked a tightrope—calling for accountability, but also “grace” for Russell. But her message is clear: voters want competence, not excuses.

Jones has since ordered additional testing of sirens and pledged to rewrite emergency protocols. In the meantime, Fire Captain John Walk will serve as interim head of CEMA. Whether that’s enough to calm public outrage remains to be seen.

For now, while questions are piling up in The Gateway to the West, once answer is certain: continuing to vote for Democrats obsessed with identity politics has drastic consequences.

[Read More: Biden Staffers Went To Great Links To Stop Kamala]